Cardboard Crushers

We're buying trading cards! Check our buylist to see what we're looking for and get a quote today.

Browse Our Magic: The Gathering Buylist

How It Works

Selling your cards is simple

1

Browse Prices

Search our buylist to see what we're buying and check current prices.

2

Ship Cards

Send us your cards following our shipping guidelines.

3

We Verify

Our team inspects and grades each card carefully.

4

Get Paid

Receive payment via your preferred method.

Card Grading

We grade cards based on these condition standards

NM
Near Mint

Minimal wear, like new

LP
Lightly Played

Minor edge wear, light scratches

MP
Moderately Played

Noticeable wear, some creases

HP
Heavily Played

Significant wear, heavy creasing

DMG
Damaged

Major damage, unplayable unsleeved

Shipping Guidelines

How to safely send us your cards

Under $50
  • Plain white envelope
  • Cards in toploader
  • Cardboard protection
  • Regular mail
$50 - $200
  • Bubble mailer or box
  • Toploaders + team bags
  • Include packing slip
  • Ship with tracking
Over $200
  • Small box + bubble wrap
  • All cards in toploaders
  • Tracking + insurance
  • Signature recommended

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to receive payment?
We typically process buylist orders within 3-5 business days of receiving your cards. Payment is sent immediately after processing.
What if my cards are graded differently than expected?
If we grade a card lower than expected, we will contact you with an updated offer. You can choose to accept the new price or have the card returned at your expense.
Do you accept foreign language cards?
Yes, we accept foreign language cards. Prices may vary from the listed English prices. Please contact us for specific quotes on foreign cards.

Check Order Status

Already submitted an order? Enter your order ID to check its status.

We pay via:Direct PayoutStore Credit